The Supreme Court has reserved judgments in three appeals arising from disputes over the nomination of All Progressives Congress (APC) candidates for the 2027 general elections in Zamfara and Ondo states, leaving the affected aspirants awaiting the final determination of their political fortunes.
The appeals, heard on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, concern the APC’s senatorial ticket for Zamfara North and its House of Representatives ticket for Owo/Ose Federal Constituency in Ondo State.
The proceedings involved three separate appeals before two five-member panels of the apex court, with the justices reserving their decisions until dates to be communicated to the parties.
The first appeal, marked SC/CV/840/2026, was filed by Senator Sahabi Ya’u against Sani Shinkafi, the APC and the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC).
The appeal challenges the judgment of the Court of Appeal, Sokoto Division, delivered on October 20, 2026, which affirmed the August 31 judgment of the Federal High Court in Gusau nullifying the APC primary election conducted on May 19 for Zamfara North Senatorial District and ordering the party to conduct a fresh primary within 14 days.
At Wednesday’s proceedings, counsel to Ya’u, Wale Balogun (SAN), adopted the appellant’s briefs of argument and urged the Supreme Court to allow the appeal.
However, counsel to Shinkafi, Bello Galadi, adopted the first respondent’s brief and urged the apex court to uphold his client’s preliminary objection and dismiss the appeal.
The APC, listed as the second respondent, was not represented by counsel, while INEC’s lawyer, M.T. Abubakar, informed the court that the commission had not filed a brief.
After listening to the submissions, Justice Tijjani Abubakar, who presided over the five-member panel, reserved judgment and directed that the date of delivery would be communicated to senior counsel representing the parties.
The other two appeals, marked SC/CV/795/2026 and SC/CV/830/2026, arose from the dispute over the APC primary election for Owo/Ose Federal Constituency in Ondo State.
The first was filed by Oluwatimehin Adelegbe, with Abdulghani Arobo, the APC and INEC listed as respondents.
The second appeal was filed by the APC, with Arobo and INEC named as respondents.
Adelegbe is challenging the October 9, 2026 judgment of the Abuja Division of the Court of Appeal, which affirmed an earlier decision of the Federal High Court recognising Arobo as the APC candidate for the constituency in the 2027 House of Representatives election.
The dispute followed the APC primary election conducted on May 16, 2026, which Adelegbe claimed to have won with 13,094 votes.
In his appeal, Adelegbe is asking the Supreme Court to overturn the decisions of the lower courts and direct INEC to recognise, publish and maintain his name and nomination particulars as the duly nominated APC candidate for Owo/Ose Federal Constituency.
His legal team, led by Joseph Daudu (SAN), argued that the Court of Appeal occasioned a miscarriage of justice by refusing his application to introduce additional evidence to establish his claim to the party’s ticket.
Daudu told the panel, presided over by Justice Mohammed Lawal Garba, that Adelegbe was excluded from the original proceedings at the Federal High Court and was only joined as a party at the Court of Appeal after filing an application.
He argued that his client should not have been denied the opportunity to present evidence which he could not have submitted at the trial court because he was not initially joined in the case.
Among the documents Adelegbe sought to introduce were an APC official candidate forwarding letter dated June 26, 2026; his Form EC9 affidavit; an INEC Candidate Nomination Portal submission receipt dated July 11, 2026; and a certified true copy of the APC Election Committee result sheet, which he claimed showed that he polled 13,094 votes.
He further contended that the Court of Appeal wrongly applied the doctrine of estoppel by standing by against him, insisting that he had neither been served with court processes nor had knowledge of the proceedings before the Federal High Court delivered its judgment on August 5, 2026.
According to Adelegbe, the failure to join him in the original suit deprived him of the opportunity to defend his claimed interest in the APC nomination and violated his constitutional right to fair hearing under Section 36(1) of the 1999 Constitution.
He also faulted the appellate court’s position on the use of originating summons in the original proceedings, arguing that the case involved serious and conflicting factual issues that required a different mode of commencement.
Additionally, Adelegbe challenged the decision which allowed Arobo to approach the Federal High Court without first exhausting the APC’s internal appeal process through its National Working Committee.
Responding, Arobo’s counsel, Onyechi Ikpeazu (SAN), adopted his client’s brief of argument and urged the Supreme Court to dismiss Adelegbe’s appeal.
Ikpeazu also drew the court’s attention to a preliminary objection challenging aspects of the reliefs sought by the appellant, particularly prayers three and four.
Emmanuel Ukala (SAN), who represented the APC, and Abdullahi Yahaya (SAN), counsel to INEC, informed the court that their respective clients had not filed briefs in Adelegbe’s appeal.
In the separate appeal filed by the APC, Ukala adopted the party’s brief and urged the Supreme Court to allow the appeal, while Ikpeazu, representing Arobo, urged the court to dismiss it.
Yahaya again informed the court that INEC had not filed a brief in that appeal.
After hearing the submissions, Justice Garba reserved judgment in both Owo/Ose appeals, stating that the dates would be communicated to senior counsel representing the parties.
The three appeals are among the growing number of pre-election disputes confronting political parties as preparations intensify for the 2027 general elections.
The Supreme Court’s eventual decisions are expected to determine the outstanding legal questions surrounding the APC nominations in the two states, particularly the competing claims to the party’s tickets for Zamfara North Senatorial District and Owo/Ose Federal Constituency.
Leave a comment